HackerTube
HomeLongsLikedHistoryWatch laterCategoriesPlaylistsSettings

Greenspan: "There is nothing to prevent the government from creating as much money as it wants."

wonkmonkCited 7× on HN, 2017-2026
YouTube
83K views · 12 years ago · news · evergreen

A two-minute clip from a March 2005 House Budget Committee hearing in which Paul Ryan asks Alan Greenspan about personal retirement accounts and social security solvency. Greenspan replies that nothing prevents the government from creating as much money as it wants.

HN commenters use it as a primary-source clip for the argument that a currency-issuing government cannot go bankrupt in its own currency.

Macroeconomics & financial crisesUS politics & elections#alangreenspan#paulryan#socialsecurity#fiatcurrency#congressionalhearing

7 comments from Hacker News

@mempko2026 · in “Alan Greenspan Dies at 100; Led Fed During Boom Before 2008 Bust”

Here is an old clip of Alan Greenspan explaining to Paul Ryan why the social security system can't go bankrupt. ▶ this video

CitesView on HN
@mempko2025 · in “Stargate Project: SoftBank, OpenAI, Oracle, MGX to build data centers”

Modern monetary systems function through two main channels: government spending and bank lending. Every dollar in circulation originates from one of these sources - either government fiscal operations (deficit spending) or bank credit creation through loans. This means all money is fundamentally based on debt, though "debt" has very different implications for a currency-issuing government versus private borrowers. Government debt operates fundamentally differently from household debt since the government controls its own currency. As former Fed Chairman Alan Greenspan noted to Congress, the U.S. can always meet any obligation denominated in dollars since it can create them. The real constraints aren't financial but economic - inflation risk and the efficient allocation of real resources. ▶ this video The key question then becomes one of political priorities and public understanding. If public opposition to beneficial government spending stems from misunderstanding how modern monetary systems work, then better education about these mechanisms could help advance important policy goals. The focus should be on managing real economic constraints rather than imaginary financial ones.

CitesView on HN
@omegaworks2021 · in “India defuses its population bomb: fertility falls to two children per woman”

>I've paid Social Security and Medicare taxes for 25 years, since my first paycheck, and it's not likely I'll ever receive anything from these programs based on current projections. This is a purely political decision. When Paul Ryan made this assertion in Congress to justify privatizing the system Alan Greenspan shot him down[1]. The government chooses how many dollars to allocate to Social Security and Medicare. Whether those dollars come from taxes elsewhere is almost entirely irrelevant. The only factor is whether seniors will get enough from the program to buy what they need to live. This has as much to do with the prices of goods as it does with the size of the benefit itself. We will need to ensure we have the production we need to meet the demand by investing in sustainable, productivity amplifying technologies. The reality is with population aging or stagnating we will need one worker to be able to produce what two or more was able to to keep prices stable. I think the pressure to do this is already being felt by workers here in the US. It's one of the main reasons why there is so much apathy from the ruling classes when it comes to ensuring workers can earn a living wage from one job. The people in charge would rather we keep the conditions such that one worker must work three jobs to scrape by than make the costly investments to increase productivity. 1. ▶ this video

CitesView on HN
@omegaworks2019 · in “The World’s Cheapest Hospital Has to Get Even Cheaper”

I knew I'd get this kneejerk reaction to "simply create and allocate the currency," I was holding out hope that responders would finish reading the sentence. What I said was: >a nation-state... can create and allocate the currency to serve this purpose. I totally agree with you in a general sense. Creating and allocating currency and distributing it to the general population equally will cause the scenario you describe. "More dollars chasing fewer goods," as Greenspan described[1]. However, if we take the hypothetical scenario that the government agrees to pay exactly the current cost of the procedure at Narayana for medical procedures , none of what you described will come to pass. Wait times at Narayana might increase because more people might come in to have the services performed, but it will not cause runaway across-the-board inflation. 1. ▶ this video

CitesView on HN
@omegaworks2019 · in “Rewarding Neglect and Punishing Investment in Struggling Neighborhoods”

Can we close the book on this "unfunded pension liability" nonsense? The government can create the raw dollars needed to fund the pensions. Just listen to Alan Greenspan himself shut down Paul Ryan's perverse anti-social security zealotry: ▶ this video

CitesView on HN
@Maro2019 · in “Berkshire Hathaway 2018 Annual Shareholder Letter [pdf]”

Mainstream economic theory is considered garbage by the majority of mainstream economists :) Joking aside, what MMT says is pretty easy to understand from reading ~100 pages and watching some YT lectures/debates, where mainstream economists also voice their opinion. A reasonably intelligent person can make up their own mind, irrespective of what others think. Finally, if you watch debates on YT, it's not true that mainstream economists say it's garbage. They usually say "MMT is essentially accounting truisms". Here's Paul Ryan asking Alan Greenspan about this: ▶ this video

CitesView on HN
@RobertoG2017 · in “South Korea considers cryptocurrency tax”

National currencies are not really in risk. Suppose that bitcoin or similar are used as currency in practice (that it's very far of happening, by the way). Even if you are able to do all your operations in a cryptocurrency, you will need to pay taxes. Governments only accept their own currency, so, you need to get it to pay taxes, so, demand of national currency is going to exist always. >> "economic vessels like national bonds and other treasuries that nations rely on to borrow money?" This is only an institutional arrangement. Nations with their currency don't really need markets to get money. For instance, in the case of USA, the FED can produce so much money as they think is appropriate (1). I think that cryptocurrency fans suffer from that old illusion that economy can be separated from politics. (1).- Video of Greenspan explaining it: ▶ this video

CitesView on HN
Money as Debt - Full Documentary47:08

Money as Debt - Full Documentary

Free Your Mind
226K views • 13 years ago
How the Fed's "Money Printer" Really Works18:01

How the Fed's "Money Printer" Really Works

Ben Felix
438K views • 6 years ago
Interview with Larry Summers, Former Secretary of the Treasury | The Problem with Jon Stewart7:52

Interview with Larry Summers, Former Secretary of the Treasury | The Problem with Jon Stewart

The Problem With Jon Stewart
1.4M views • 3 years ago
David Mitchell on Tax Avoidance from The Last Leg3:29

David Mitchell on Tax Avoidance from The Last Leg

Political News
458K views • 10 years ago
Milton Friedman Speaks: Money and Inflation (B1230) - Full Video1:26:04

Milton Friedman Speaks: Money and Inflation (B1230) - Full Video

Free To Choose Network
1.5M views • 10 years ago
The Collapse of The American Dream Explained in Animation29:55

The Collapse of The American Dream Explained in Animation

doctordude
11M views • 15 years ago
Fear the Boom and Bust: Keynes vs. Hayek - The Original Economics Rap Battle!6:18

Fear the Boom and Bust: Keynes vs. Hayek - The Original Economics Rap Battle!

Radical Discourse
8.9M views • 16 years ago
The IOU Machine: How Currency Is Created | Hidden Secrets of Money Ep. 429:35

The IOU Machine: How Currency Is Created | Hidden Secrets of Money Ep. 4

GoldSilver
11.1M views • 13 years ago
Money creation in the modern economy - Quarterly Bulletin5:08

Money creation in the modern economy - Quarterly Bulletin

Bank of England
281K views • 12 years ago
Peter Schiff Mortgage Bankers Speech Nov/13/061:12:41

Peter Schiff Mortgage Bankers Speech Nov/13/06

Peter Schiff
610K views • 17 years ago
Republic, Lost (my favorite version)48:12

Republic, Lost (my favorite version)

lessig
9K views • 15 years ago
Money as Debt I - Revised Edition 2009 (Full Movie)46:21

Money as Debt I - Revised Edition 2009 (Full Movie)

Ethaniel RockX
291K views • 11 years ago
Inequality: Why are the rich getting richer?3:01

Inequality: Why are the rich getting richer?

Positive Money UK
130K views • 13 years ago
Austerity: The History of a Dangerous Idea | Mark Blyth | Talks at Google1:07:30

Austerity: The History of a Dangerous Idea | Mark Blyth | Talks at Google

Talks at Google
347K views • 13 years ago
Margin Call Best Quote by Will Emerson2:09

Margin Call Best Quote by Will Emerson

chrislaucn
3.1M views • 14 years ago
8/28/2006 Peter Schiff On Kudlow & Co: Predicts The US Economic Collapse8:15

8/28/2006 Peter Schiff On Kudlow & Co: Predicts The US Economic Collapse

PhilDeCarolis
560K views • 18 years ago
Jim Cramer: "Bear Stearns is Fine!" Tues, 3/11/081:34

Jim Cramer: "Bear Stearns is Fine!" Tues, 3/11/08

politiclips
557K views • 18 years ago
Robert Kennedy on GDP1:46

Robert Kennedy on GDP

Wimble Don
83K views • 8 years ago
Fight of the Century: Keynes vs. Hayek - Economics Rap Battle Round Two8:43

Fight of the Century: Keynes vs. Hayek - Economics Rap Battle Round Two

Radical Discourse
5.9M views • 15 years ago
Buy, Borrow, Die: How America's Ultrawealthy Stay That Way1:53

Buy, Borrow, Die: How America's Ultrawealthy Stay That Way

ProPublica
475K views • 5 years ago