HackerTube
HomeLongsLikedHistoryWatch laterCategoriesPlaylistsSettings

Peloton Tread+ Treadmill Safety Incident

U.S. Consumer Product Safety CommissionCited 8× on HN, 2021-2022
YouTube
1.5M views · 5 years ago · news · news

A short silent video from the US Consumer Product Safety Commission warning consumers to stop using the Peloton Tread+. It shows a child being pulled under the treadmill, and it preceded Peloton's recall.

HN cites it as evidence in debates over the treadmill's design flaw and parental responsibility, often with a warning that it is disturbing.

Product & industrial designEngineering & making (other)#peloton#treadmill#cpsc#recall#productdesign

8 comments from Hacker News

@29athrowaway2022 · in “Peloton replaces CEO and lays off 2,800 people”

Why I will never buy any Peloton product for my home... Peloton Tread+ Treadmill Safety Incident: ▶ this video (viewer discretion is advised)

CriticalView on HN
@fastball2021 · in “Peloton to invest $400M to build its first U.S. manufacturing facility in Ohio”

Yes, a plastic guard creates opportunities for catching fingers and clothing, but (unsurprisingly) people think this is preferable to their child's head getting caught in the treadmill[1]. A child was killed by one of these things. It is absolutely a massive design flaw that this treadmill lacks a protective guard and/or an automatic cutoff that triggers when it sees an unexpected level of resistance. You know, like if a child's head gets caught in it. [1] ▶ this video

CriticalView on HN
@Johnny5552021 · in “Peloton recalling all treadmills after reports of injuries, one death”

Did you watch the video that was widely circulated in the news? A child is playing with a ball (around 12" in diameter), it gets sucked under and traps his hands, then the treadmill pulls his entire body under as the treadmill itself (which weighs 300-450lb) moves on top of him. In this case the child was lucky that the ball didn't burst so he was able to climb back out. ▶ this video

CitesView on HN
@gvb2021 · in “Peloton recalling all treadmills after reports of injuries, one death”

The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission released a video of a child being sucked under the machine. The child was not injured in this instance, but the video is horrifying to watch. ▶ this video

CitesView on HN
@hagy2021 · in “Regulators urge safety recall of Peloton treadmill after child dies”

I agree. The CPSC graphic video [0], graphically demonstrates the "safety failure" of a Pelton treadmill with two young children playing on an active treadmill unsupervised. While I certainly agree Pelton and other manufactures should attempt to mitigate the dangers of such a negligent situation, I was astonished that parents would allow this to happen. Imagine the same video, but replace the treadmill with a loaded bench press. Pelton highlights that there is a safety key required to operate the machine and that parents are instructed to store it in a secure location inaccessible to children. [1] No treadmill manufacturer can ever fully eliminate the dangers of an active treadmill to young children and pets, and therefore I think this safety key is the essential piece. I find this similar to locking power tools away from curious young hands. I don't want this to lead to additional regulation and compliance. Such regulation could even mislead consumers as to the danger of a treadmill. E.g., requiring some autodetection of a stuck belt to stop the motor. A foolproof mechanism would be not only expensive, but require regular inspection and maintenance to guarantee it performs this function. One could trust this mechanism while neglecting maintenance and therefore be further negligent in not securing the safety key away from children. [0] ▶ this video [1] link

CitesView on HN
@omnicognate2021 · in “Regulators urge safety recall of Peloton treadmill after child dies”

If you do a google images search for "running treadmill" you'll see most of them have some design aspect that would prevent the accident shown in the video, most commonly a bar or guard of some sort that would stop a child or large object being dragged under. Edit: in case you haven't seen the video: ▶ this video

CitesView on HN
@romwell2021 · in “Regulators urge safety recall of Peloton treadmill after child dies”

There are many treadmills out there. And those treadmills don't tell to pull people underneath them , like this device did. Let's not be facetious here, Peloton didn't get CPSC's attention because it is a treadmill -- it got that attention because it is an unsafe treadmill. As far as treadmills go, preventing being pulled underneath has been a solved problem. EDIT: compare and contrast: what Peloton does [1] vs. a $700 treadmill design [2]. [1] ▶ this video [2] link

CriticalView on HN
@rgbrenner2021 · in “Regulators urge safety recall of Peloton treadmill after child dies”

Most treadmills have a guard or plastic covering on the bottom that stops the tread from pulling something underneath it. From pictures, the peloton treadmill doesnt have this... so I would guess if anything gets between the back of the device and the floor, it'll pull it under the machine. Edit: confirmed (warning: video shows a child being injured): ▶ this video

CitesView on HN
Milton Friedman justifies not recalling the ford pinto6:57

Milton Friedman justifies not recalling the ford pinto

RepublicansSuckDlCK
112K views • 13 years ago
Fight Club - The Recall Coordinator's Formula1:34

Fight Club - The Recall Coordinator's Formula

Montag Beeblebrox
251K views • 16 years ago
How dangerous are magnetic items near an MRI magnet?2:49

How dangerous are magnetic items near an MRI magnet?

practiCal fMRI
19.1M views • 16 years ago
[842] Picked in 2 Seconds! Amazon’s Choice “High Security Padlock”3:28

[842] Picked in 2 Seconds! Amazon’s Choice “High Security Padlock”

LockPickingLawyer
1.7M views • 7 years ago
Why Electric Bikes are More Dangerous than Motorcycles6:19

Why Electric Bikes are More Dangerous than Motorcycles

FortNine
2.2M views • 5 years ago
Uncovered - Dangerous Secrets of the DOT Helmet Standard9:12

Uncovered - Dangerous Secrets of the DOT Helmet Standard

FortNine
1.1M views • 8 years ago
DJI Phantom 2 Injury1:21

DJI Phantom 2 Injury

Armando Izquierdo
173K views • 12 years ago
TMS Bicycle, stable without gyros or trail (TMS=two-mass-skate)2:39

TMS Bicycle, stable without gyros or trail (TMS=two-mass-skate)

Arend Schwab
44K views • 15 years ago
Resveratrol – The Unfortunate (& Scandalous) Story18:39

Resveratrol – The Unfortunate (& Scandalous) Story

Dr Brad Stanfield
208K views • 4 years ago
Horrific USB power supply fault.  (Electrocution risk.)28:21

Horrific USB power supply fault. (Electrocution risk.)

bigclivedotcom
1.2M views • 10 years ago
Avoiding Negative Side Effects: Concrete Problems in AI Safety part 19:33

Avoiding Negative Side Effects: Concrete Problems in AI Safety part 1

Robert Miles AI Safety
161K views • 9 years ago
I Love Helmets0:31

I Love Helmets

wakoiii
13.2M views • 12 years ago
Lessons from a Can Opener21:48

Lessons from a Can Opener

Technology Connections
3M views • 4 years ago
Chest Freezers; What they tell us about designing for X26:54

Chest Freezers; What they tell us about designing for X

Technology Connections
2.9M views • 6 years ago
DYSON ANIMAL BALLS | It blows!24:29

DYSON ANIMAL BALLS | It blows!

AvE
1.2M views • 8 years ago
The CED: RCA's Very Late, Very Weird Video Gamble (Pt. 1)23:33

The CED: RCA's Very Late, Very Weird Video Gamble (Pt. 1)

Technology Connections
2.9M views • 7 years ago
Cyclists' hearts: can you be so fit that you die?7:19

Cyclists' hearts: can you be so fit that you die?

Medlife Crisis
2.2M views • 8 years ago
The most deadly project on the Internet15:14

The most deadly project on the Internet

bigclivedotcom
6.8M views • 4 years ago
Table Saw Safety: My Accident and How to Avoid Your Own8:35

Table Saw Safety: My Accident and How to Avoid Your Own

MrFixItDIY
80K views • 8 years ago
OSCON 2011:  Karen Sandler14:26

OSCON 2011: Karen Sandler

O'Reilly
15K views • 15 years ago