HackerTube
HomeLongsLikedHistoryWatch laterCategoriesPlaylistsSettings

EEVblog #1333 - Nuclear Diamond Self-Charging Battery DEBUNKED!

EEVblogCited 9× on HN, 2020-2024
YouTube
195K views · 6 years ago · commentary · news

Dave Jones of EEVblog debunks the marketing claims of the self-charging nano nuclear diamond battery from NDB Inc. He argues it is no better than existing 100uW betavoltaic batteries, with an added graphene supercapacitor.

Repeatedly linked under hype stories about nuclear diamond batteries as the definitive debunk.

Renewables, batteries & storageElectronics & circuit design#betavoltaic#nuclearbattery#debunk#ndb#supercapacitor

9 comments from Hacker News

@0xbadc0de52024 · in “A tiny radioactive battery could keep your future phone running for 50 years”

These are woefully underpowered for consumer electronics and always will be - only really useful for maintaining volatile memory. This idea has actually been debunked more than once. ▶ this video link

CriticalView on HN
@gus_massa2022 · in “Turning nuclear waste into diamond batteries”

It was heavily discussed a few years ago, for example in link They last for a log time, but the important detail is that they have very low power, like 1mW with the size factor of a normal battery, so you need like a dozen for a (old) wrist watch and s few hundred to turn on a led. More details in: link ▶ this video (EEVblog)

CriticalView on HN
@mikewarot2021 · in “Ask HN: What under-the-radar technology are you excited about?”

Why are you interested in this? If it is for anything other than very LOW power (microwatts), you're going to be disappointed. It is essentially a beta emitter hooked to a capacitor via some electronics to handle voltage conversion. The thing is the beta source is use it or lose it, and very low power. If you scaled this up to power a Tesla, it would be a nightmare, as it would need to dissipate the full power the car requires, all the time, or it would melt down (aka Fukashima) For a longer debunk - ▶ this video

CriticalView on HN
@gus_massa2021 · in “Diamond battery powered by nuclear waste runs for 28,000 years”

It is not clear that they have a real working prototype. The current is very low, only 100uW, and there are similar batteries made with tritium. More info in a video by EEVblog eevblog had a good video about this product: ▶ this video (it's old, but I can't find any evidence of improvements.) Also, there is a calculation of the low the maximal current per kilogram in link

CriticalView on HN
@colejohnson662021 · in “Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges much faster”

To add to the sample size of n=1, a few months ago, there were many articles about “nano diamond” batteries that will supposedly solve the radioactive waste problem. Dave Jones of EEVBlog debunked it pretty quickly: ▶ this video Basically, every few months, a company comes out with claims that battery tech or e-waste has been revolutionized , but it’s always a bunch of bunk claims made using a multitude of weasel words.

CriticalView on HN
@ChrisGranger2020 · in “A battery made from nuclear waste that can last 28,000 years”

This nonexistent product has been discussed and debunked here before. Here's EEVblog's take: ▶ this video

CriticalView on HN
@diimdeep2020 · in “Gravitricity – Fast, long-life energy storage”

Where is innovation and efficiency ? To me it smells like ▶ this video and all about patents, marketing and money burning, but I don't know as much as these professors do so maybe I am wrong.

CriticalView on HN
@gus_massa2020 · in “Scientists turn nuclear waste into diamond batteries”

It is not clear that they have a real working prototype. The current is very low, only 100uW, and there are similar batteries made with tritium. More info in a video by EEVblog eevblog had a good video about this product: ▶ this video Also, there is a calculation of the low the maximal current per kilogram in link

CriticalView on HN
@josephcsible2020 · in “Nano-diamond battery that "lasts for 28k years" closer to commercialization”

EEVblog did a debunk of this at ▶ this video Basically, the power density of these are so low that they're useless for most applications. Sure, it might last 28,000 years, but you're only getting 100 microwatts from a battery the size of a normal AA battery.

CriticalView on HN
EEVblog #1001 - uBeam Ultrasonic Wireless Charging DEBUNKED!15:25

EEVblog #1001 - uBeam Ultrasonic Wireless Charging DEBUNKED!

EEVblog
133K views • 9 years ago
EEVblog #632 - Solar Roadways Are RUBBISH!32:01

EEVblog #632 - Solar Roadways Are RUBBISH!

EEVblog
543K views • 12 years ago
The Energy Vault is a Dumb Idea, Here's Why3:50

The Energy Vault is a Dumb Idea, Here's Why

Adam Something
4.7M views • 4 years ago
Testing LCBs (Lithium Ceramic Batteries) || The Future of Battery Technology?7:24

Testing LCBs (Lithium Ceramic Batteries) || The Future of Battery Technology?

GreatScott!
1.6M views • 8 years ago
The Battery That Refuses to Explode | NOVA2:07

The Battery That Refuses to Explode | NOVA

NOVA PBS Official
78K views • 9 years ago
The Great Stranding: How Inaccurate Mainstream LCOE Estimates are Creating a Trillion-Dollar Bubble18:58

The Great Stranding: How Inaccurate Mainstream LCOE Estimates are Creating a Trillion-Dollar Bubble

RethinkX
38K views • 5 years ago
Scavenging rechargeable lithium cells from the roadside15:30

Scavenging rechargeable lithium cells from the roadside

bigclivedotcom
263K views • 4 years ago
Fun with ultracapacitors!!6:11

Fun with ultracapacitors!!

Afrotechmods
2.2M views • 15 years ago
Zero Mass Water -BUSTED!18:01

Zero Mass Water -BUSTED!

Thunderf00t
1.1M views • 8 years ago
California's Renewable Energy Problem18:01

California's Renewable Energy Problem

Real Engineering
1.6M views • 7 years ago
You are being misled about renewable energy technology.1:32:00

You are being misled about renewable energy technology.

Technology Connections
5M views • 9 months ago
The Liquid Metal Battery: Innovation in stationary electricity storage1:04:12

The Liquid Metal Battery: Innovation in stationary electricity storage

School of Convergence Science
518K views • 7 years ago
Should Google Go Nuclear? Clean, cheap, nuclear power (no, really)1:32:38

Should Google Go Nuclear? Clean, cheap, nuclear power (no, really)

GoogleTalksArchive
23K views • 14 years ago
Wireless vs wired DC fast charging efficiency test25:40

Wireless vs wired DC fast charging efficiency test

Bjørn Nyland
67K views • 4 years ago
The Truth about Hydrogen14:58

The Truth about Hydrogen

Real Engineering
5.7M views • 8 years ago
Should Google Go Nuclear? Clean, cheap, nuclear power...1:32:44

Should Google Go Nuclear? Clean, cheap, nuclear power...

Google TechTalks
74K views • 19 years ago
TOTAL teardown of a lithium phone battery.21:30

TOTAL teardown of a lithium phone battery.

bigclivedotcom
376K views • 11 years ago
Rethinking Energy -- 100% Solar, Wind and Batteries Is Just The Beginning12:02

Rethinking Energy -- 100% Solar, Wind and Batteries Is Just The Beginning

Tony Seba
90K views • 5 years ago
Britain's largest battery is actually a lake4:56

Britain's largest battery is actually a lake

Tom Scott
2.2M views • 8 years ago
Carbon Capture Isn't Real3:51

Carbon Capture Isn't Real

Adam Something
988K views • 4 years ago