HackerTube
HomeLongsLikedHistoryWatch laterCategoriesPlaylistsSettings

Gall--Peters Projection

UsefulClips2 HN recommenders · recommended in 2 months, 2015-2024
YouTube
2.5M views · 16 years ago · comedy · evergreen

A short clip from The West Wing in which characters argue for the Gall-Peters map projection over Mercator. It dramatizes how standard maps distort the relative size of countries.

It is the go-to link in any HN thread on map projections, usually posted as the obligatory West Wing reference.

Film & TV clipsData visualization & information design#gall-peters#mercator#cartography#westwing

8 comments from Hacker News

@brianshaler2024 · in “A flat map with the least error possible: The Gott-Goldberg-Vanderbei projection”

I made an interactive WebGL implementation of this without realizing it was a thing: link I don't really agree with the claims in the articles linked in OP, and don't find it to be a generally useful projection, even for the tool I made using it. It was novel as a representation that included daylight context (instead of just "what time is it there?" it helped express "is it getting dark there?") that preserved area better than a globe and was more intuitive than a day/night waveform on a rectilinear projection. But ultimately, if you're showing anything that has to do with populations (cities, people) pretty much any projection will waste large amounts of space on oceans and unpopulated land regions. That is to say, before choosing a favorite map projection, I think it's probably better to not to use a map projection at all unless you're going for a hike or setting sail. Somebody beat me to the obligatory xkcd, but this West Wing bit is my go-to for map projection discussions: ▶ this video I like framing map projections by what they prioritize or sacrifice—fidelity in axis, position, size—and what projection is "best" depends entirely on which characteristics are more important. I disagree with OP's claim about this projection being "the most accurate flat map of the Earth yet" though haven't put a ton of thought into the physical, back-to-back definition of "flat" vs on-screen.

CitesView on HN
@resolutebat2023 · in “Maps Distort How We See the World”

I'd like to think you're being ironic here, but I suspect you're not, so no: the vast majority of the world is outside the US and has not, in fact, seen an obscure episode of a TV drama about American politics. For others who haven't, here it is: ▶ this video Although the projection it proclaims as superior, Gall-Peters, has grievous flaws of its own. link

CitesView on HN
@greggman32021 · in “Reimagining projections for the interactive maps era”

obligatory link to West Wing scene where they point out the political implications of the mercator projection ▶ this video

CitesView on HN
@ZeroCool2u2020 · in “The True Size Of Countries: Mercator projection”

I still remember the first time I learned about this. I was watching the West Wing (Season 2 Episode 16[1] which explains the problem pretty quickly) for the first time in the early 2010's and was absolutely blown away that we'd never been taught about this in public school (U.S.A.). Having graduated High School and a couple of years through undergrad, and just then realizing that my entire perception of the relative size, and in some cases position(!), of the continents is basically just wrong. It was actually a generally useful thought exercise though, because it really forced me to confront the fact that I need to consistently reflect on whether my previous assumptions on even basic topics hold true. I'm not sure it would be worthwhile to advocate for changing the default projection at this point due to the logistics, but at least teaching kids about the issue, which can be covered in no more than a few minutes and is obviously not super complex, just so they're aware of it seems totally worth it! [1]: ▶ this video

CitesView on HN
@eyelidlessness2020 · in “The True Size Of Countries: Mercator projection”

Requisite West Wing scene[1] on the subject (which is probably always going to be my top YouTube search because it’s fantastic). [1]: ▶ this video

RecommendsView on HN
@Amorymeltzer2015 · in “The last unmapped places on Earth”

The West Wing clip on maps is still one of the best ways to teach someone about how different our classic maps are from reality: ▶ this video

Strongly recommendsView on HN
@teh_klev2015 · in “Steve Wozniak on Steve Jobs Movie”

I dunno, I like most of Sorkin's work. However I couldn't watch "The Newsroom" past four or five episodes. You're right, it seems like The West Wing's characters all re-hashed into TV news characters and it was too cloying. I still go back and re-watch The West Wing every couple of years. Yes some of it is cringe-worthy, but as a non-US citiizen when first broadcast I learned a few things about US politics and it caused me find out more, especially from a historical point of view. He also does some nice things such as dropping in interesting educational nuggets such as the Peters Projection cartography stuff in the second "Big Block of Cheese" episode (S2E16) [0]. [0]: ▶ this video

CitesView on HN
@teh_klev2015 · in “Printing a wall-sized world map and what I've learned from it”

And obligatory West Wing "Gall Peters Projection" clip: "What the hell is that?" "It's where you've been living this whole time" ▶ this video

CitesView on HN
Why are we changing maps?  (from The West Wing)3:58

Why are we changing maps? (from The West Wing)

SaltLakeUsersGroup
800K views • 14 years ago
H3: Tiling the Earth with Hexagons25:39

H3: Tiling the Earth with Hexagons

Uber Engineering
53K views • 8 years ago
Google Earth’s Incredible 3D Imagery, Explained8:09

Google Earth’s Incredible 3D Imagery, Explained

Nat and Friends
3.1M views • 9 years ago
Animated Voting Methods6:18

Animated Voting Methods

Unify The Vote
16K views • 9 years ago
Mad Men - The Carousel (Higher Quality)3:26

Mad Men - The Carousel (Higher Quality)

TomR35
2.4M views • 18 years ago
Visualizing the 4d numbers Quaternions31:51

Visualizing the 4d numbers Quaternions

3Blue1Brown
5.6M views • 8 years ago
Disney's Practical Guide to Path Tracing9:32

Disney's Practical Guide to Path Tracing

Walt Disney Animation Studios
914K views • 10 years ago
Quantum Field Theory visualized15:53

Quantum Field Theory visualized

ScienceClic English
2.7M views • 6 years ago
Enemy of the state - Freeze,Rotate,Zoom,Focus,Enhance!1:16

Enemy of the state - Freeze,Rotate,Zoom,Focus,Enhance!

Movietwist
221K views • 15 years ago
A Better Default Colormap for Matplotlib | SciPy 2015 | Nathaniel Smith and Stéfan van der Walt19:09

A Better Default Colormap for Matplotlib | SciPy 2015 | Nathaniel Smith and Stéfan van der Walt

Enthought
177K views • 11 years ago
A new way to visualize General Relativity11:33

A new way to visualize General Relativity

ScienceClic English
3.6M views • 6 years ago
Visualizing Data Using t-SNE55:10

Visualizing Data Using t-SNE

Google TechTalks
204K views • 13 years ago
Gerrymandering: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO)19:34

Gerrymandering: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO)

LastWeekTonight
12.6M views • 9 years ago
Hawaii 5-0 Subway Product Placement0:50

Hawaii 5-0 Subway Product Placement

Ewhwlen
2M views • 14 years ago
The Tube Map nearly looked very different11:24

The Tube Map nearly looked very different

Map Men
2.6M views • 4 years ago
The Known Universe by AMNH #datavisualization6:31

The Known Universe by AMNH #datavisualization

American Museum of Natural History
17.3M views • 16 years ago
3D Gaussian Splatting - Why Graphics Will Never Be The Same2:12

3D Gaussian Splatting - Why Graphics Will Never Be The Same

IndividualKex
2M views • 3 years ago
Scene from Moneyball - What is the problem?4:16

Scene from Moneyball - What is the problem?

Adam Staab
6.5M views • 12 years ago
Bret Victor - Drawing Dynamic Visualizations35:16

Bret Victor - Drawing Dynamic Visualizations

Colin McDonnell
17K views • 11 years ago
Gabbard Diagram for Low Earth Orbit 1959-20214:09

Gabbard Diagram for Low Earth Orbit 1959-2021

Tim
3K views • 5 years ago