HackerTube
HomeLongsLikedHistoryWatch laterCategoriesPlaylistsSettings

Does the language you speak change how you think?

Tom Scott1 HN recommender · recommended in 1 month, 2023-2024
YouTube
1.6M views · 3 years ago · explainer · evergreen

Tom Scott, with linguists Gretchen McCulloch and Molly Ruhl, examines whether the language you speak changes how you think. The short answer is mostly no, with caveats about the weak version of the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis.

Linked as a concise, accessible rebuttal whenever linguistic relativity comes up in a thread.

Language & linguisticsConsciousness & cognition#sapir-whorf#linguistics#languageandthought#tomscott#cognition

3 comments from Hacker News

@cardanome2024 · in “Orwell: The Rewrite”

Note that Orwell promotes an hard form of the Sapir Whorf hypothesis called linguistic determinism meaning that a language would make it impossible think certain thoughts. This is obviously wrong. Have you ever experienced anything for which you didn't have the words to explain? This already proves that you can feel and think things that are not easily expressed in the languages you know. Also some people don't even think in words but are more visual thinkers. But even for the softer version, linguistic relativism, these is not much hard evidence. You subjective experience is not easily measurable. Yes, the act of learning new languages can gives you new perspectives and enrich you as a person because it gives you access to a whole new culture but that is different to saying you can suddenly experience new forms of emotions because you didn't have the words for it before or see more colors. I recommend this Tom Scott video on the issue: ▶ this video

RecommendsView on HN
@wilg2024 · in “Our language, our world”

Tom Scott recently did a video about how linguistic relativity (Sapir-Whorf) is almost certainly not true: ▶ this video It's an alluring idea, but it's been debunked.

CitesView on HN
@elvis10ten2023 · in “There's something going on with AI startups in France”

Related video which I just remembered: ▶ this video So it seems languages might not change how you think, but might be able to emphasize certain aspects of things like you allude to (I believe).

CitesView on HN
RSA ANIMATE: Language as a Window into Human Nature10:54

RSA ANIMATE: Language as a Window into Human Nature

Royal Society of Arts
1.6M views • 15 years ago
Your Brain Hallucinates Your Conscious Reality | Anil Seth | TED17:01

Your Brain Hallucinates Your Conscious Reality | Anil Seth | TED

TED
12M views • 9 years ago
why typing like this is sometimes okay.4:31

why typing like this is sometimes okay.

Tom Scott
5.4M views • 7 years ago
Why our IQ levels are higher than our grandparents' | James Flynn18:41

Why our IQ levels are higher than our grandparents' | James Flynn

TED
3.2M views • 13 years ago
The Stuff of Thought | Steven Pinker | Talks at Google1:15:05

The Stuff of Thought | Steven Pinker | Talks at Google

Talks at Google
419K views • 19 years ago
Your Body Language May Shape Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED21:03

Your Body Language May Shape Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED

TED
29.4M views • 14 years ago
Stephen Krashen on Language Acquisition15:25

Stephen Krashen on Language Acquisition

Mark Rounds
1.5M views • 16 years ago
Do we see reality as it is? | Donald Hoffman | TED21:51

Do we see reality as it is? | Donald Hoffman | TED

TED
3.1M views • 11 years ago
The Concept of Language (Noam Chomsky)27:44

The Concept of Language (Noam Chomsky)

UW Video
2.1M views • 12 years ago
23. Language1:42:47

23. Language

Stanford
1.2M views • 15 years ago
Stephen Krashen: Language Acquisition and Comprehensible Input15:26

Stephen Krashen: Language Acquisition and Comprehensible Input

Tarek Hamza
186K views • 10 years ago
Was Penrose Right? NEW EVIDENCE For Quantum Effects In The Brain19:19

Was Penrose Right? NEW EVIDENCE For Quantum Effects In The Brain

PBS Space Time
1.1M views • 2 years ago
Edward Gibson: Human Language, Psycholinguistics, Syntax, Grammar & LLMs | Lex Fridman Podcast #4262:50:45

Edward Gibson: Human Language, Psycholinguistics, Syntax, Grammar & LLMs | Lex Fridman Podcast #426

Lex Fridman
471K views • 2 years ago
The Hyperbolic Geometry of DMT Experiences (@Harvard Science of Psychedelics Club)1:06:15

The Hyperbolic Geometry of DMT Experiences (@Harvard Science of Psychedelics Club)

Qualia Research Institute
1.4M views • 7 years ago
If Brains are Computers, Who Designs the Software? - with Daniel Dennett1:16:22

If Brains are Computers, Who Designs the Software? - with Daniel Dennett

The Royal Institution
873K views • 9 years ago
So... the minute hand shows progression — apparently we think of time in wildly different ways18:15

So... the minute hand shows progression — apparently we think of time in wildly different ways

Technology Connextras
706K views • 4 years ago
The surprising pattern behind color names around the world6:46

The surprising pattern behind color names around the world

Vox
8.4M views • 9 years ago
Optical illusions show how we see | Beau Lotto19:00

Optical illusions show how we see | Beau Lotto

TED
3.5M views • 17 years ago
George Lakoff: Moral Politics58:58

George Lakoff: Moral Politics

University of California Television (UCTV)
201K views • 18 years ago
RSA ANIMATE: The Divided Brain11:48

RSA ANIMATE: The Divided Brain

Royal Society of Arts
2.2M views • 15 years ago