HackerTube
HomeLongsLikedHistoryWatch laterCategoriesPlaylistsSettings

Giving birth costs a lot. Hospitals won't tell you how much.

Vox1 HN recommender · recommended in 1 month, 2017-2022
YouTube
3.4M views · 10 years ago · explainer · dated

A Vox reporter tries to learn what his son's birth would cost before it happens and fails, showing how opaque US hospital pricing is even for the most common procedure.

HN cites it as the go-to example of how impossible it is to get prices in advance for US medical care.

Medicine & infectious diseaseMedia, journalism & propagandaMicroeconomics & behavioral economics#hospitalprices#childbirth#pricetransparency#healthinsurance#vox

7 comments from Hacker News

@AlotOfReading2022 · in “Surgery estimated cost $1,300. Then the Bill Came: $229,000”

You can try to comparison shop all you want, but no hospital will give you details in the chargemaster if they aren't legally obligated to. Even if you are in a position to shop around, journalists have documented their futile attempts to do price estimation for routine procedures. Here's one example: ▶ this video There have been recent laws that requiring publishing some of that information (which are being heavily contested), but comparison shopping remains effectively impossible in the US.

CitesView on HN
@elliekelly2021 · in “US doctor forgives $650k in medical bills for cancer patients”

Reminds me of the Vox reporter who tried to get a hospital quote for how much it would cost his wife to have a baby: ▶ this video I’m sure you can guess the outcome.

CitesView on HN
@empath752019 · in “A Common Blood Test Can Cost $11 or Almost $1k”

Hospitals won’t tell you the costs of treatment ahead of time, even for easily predictable items like baby delivery. It’s impossible to shop around. ▶ this video

CitesView on HN
@drchewbacca2019 · in “Ask HN: What is your money-making side project outside programming?”

I find it surprising that the US is seen as strongly free market when things like this crop up all over the place. Here's a video of someone failing to get pricing in advance for a medical procedure and an article about how many simple tasks need licences. The fact that a lot of areas only have 1 broadband provider blows my mind. ▶ this video link link

CitesView on HN
@elicash2017 · in “Emergency rooms are monopolies”

Relevant: ▶ this video The "existing legislation and regulation" section is pretty interesting for wikipedia: link

CitesView on HN
@elicash2017 · in “Thoughts on Insurance”

Here's a great video that I think is related to this topic about the near-impossibility of finding out the cost of giving birth: ▶ this video I'd imagine the reasons for the complexity are the same as an injury. Edit: Just a thought... What if enough consumers went line-by-line AFTER the fact and shared what the specific breakdown of every item cost? So then you'd be able to say, okay, at this hospital them giving us an Advil cost $X and them doing this procedure cost $Y. Some way of making the master price list for how much individual items cost public and grouping together ones that generally appear together...

RecommendsView on HN
@pwinnski2017 · in “'Legitimate' US healthcare pricing could reduce costs by a third”

You seem to be literally the only person who has been able to get straight answers from anyone on anything related to health care. As you can probably see from this thread, most of us would have the same reaction: impotent frustration. I can go to another dealer if I don't get straight answers. I can walk away at any point up until the final signature. This is simply not an analogous situation, as evidenced by the repeated testimony of everyone here. And this guy: ▶ this video

CitesView on HN
Adam Ruins Everything - The Real Reason Hospitals Are So Expensive | truTV5:33

Adam Ruins Everything - The Real Reason Hospitals Are So Expensive | truTV

truTV
6.3M views • 9 years ago
Why Are American Health Care Costs So High?7:53

Why Are American Health Care Costs So High?

vlogbrothers
7.7M views • 13 years ago
Milton Friedman Speaks: The Economics of Medical Care (B1234) - Full Video45:27

Milton Friedman Speaks: The Economics of Medical Care (B1234) - Full Video

Free To Choose Network
86K views • 10 years ago
327 - Choices, costs, and challenges in US healthcare: insurance, drug pricing, & potential reforms2:45:38

327 - Choices, costs, and challenges in US healthcare: insurance, drug pricing, & potential reforms

Peter Attia MD
43K views • 1 year ago
Marketing to Doctors: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO)17:13

Marketing to Doctors: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO)

LastWeekTonight
13.3M views • 11 years ago
Organ & Body Donations: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO)31:37

Organ & Body Donations: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO)

LastWeekTonight
5M views • 2 years ago
A real, not-clickbaity, average Chinese wet market4:26

A real, not-clickbaity, average Chinese wet market

Chinese Cooking Demystified
909K views • 6 years ago
Vaccines: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO)27:15

Vaccines: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO)

LastWeekTonight
27.4M views • 9 years ago
The Epidemic of Fake Disease20:58

The Epidemic of Fake Disease

Medlife Crisis
2.4M views • 6 years ago
Martin Shkreli on Drug Price Hikes and Playing the World’s Villain16:30

Martin Shkreli on Drug Price Hikes and Playing the World’s Villain

VICE
4M views • 10 years ago
Vaccines and Autism: A Measured Response1:44:10

Vaccines and Autism: A Measured Response

hbomberguy
13.2M views • 5 years ago
The medical test paradox, and redesigning Bayes' rule21:14

The medical test paradox, and redesigning Bayes' rule

3Blue1Brown
1.4M views • 5 years ago
Why Are Birthrates Plummeting Worldwide?26:45

Why Are Birthrates Plummeting Worldwide?

Patrick Boyle
653K views • 1 year ago
Penn and Teller on Vaccinations1:31

Penn and Teller on Vaccinations

UltraMiraculous
7.3M views • 16 years ago
If money was no object, should you run every medical test?2:52

If money was no object, should you run every medical test?

Medlife Crisis
263K views • 8 years ago
How Fox News has shifted its coronavirus rhetoric1:42

How Fox News has shifted its coronavirus rhetoric

Washington Post
903K views • 6 years ago
Jon Stewart On Vaccine Science And The Wuhan Lab Theory8:38

Jon Stewart On Vaccine Science And The Wuhan Lab Theory

The Late Show with Stephen Colbert
8.6M views • 5 years ago
Pelosi: "We Have to Pass the Bill So That You Can Find Out What Is In It"0:10

Pelosi: "We Have to Pass the Bill So That You Can Find Out What Is In It"

PoliJAM
740K views • 16 years ago
The next outbreak? We’re not ready | Bill Gates | TED8:37

The next outbreak? We’re not ready | Bill Gates | TED

TED
38.9M views • 11 years ago
The Lottery: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO)14:36

The Lottery: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO)

LastWeekTonight
16M views • 12 years ago