HackerTube
HomeLongsLikedHistoryWatch laterCategoriesPlaylistsSettings

Is Nuclear Energy Green?

Sabine Hossenfelder2 HN recommenders · recommended in 2 months, 2022-2022
YouTube
1M views · 4 years ago · commentary · dated

Sabine Hossenfelder weighs the arguments for and against nuclear power, covering waste, fuel supply and newer reactor designs. She is skeptical that fast breeders and thorium solve the problems.

Cited in nuclear energy debates, especially for uranium supply limits and why new reactor types fall short of claims.

Nuclear power & fusionClimate policy, solutions & debate#uraniumsupply#fastbreeders#thorium#climate#energypolicy

6 comments from Hacker News

@wickedsickeune2022 · in “Europe is in danger of rolling electricity shortages”

I would recommend that you watch this video: ▶ this video It's quite well researched, and for someone who was also wondering why there is European aversion towards nuclear power, it showed me that it's not that simple. Nuclear power is quite inconvenient and not as magical "free energy" as it seems.

RecommendsView on HN
@Sporktacular2022 · in “Who killed nuclear energy and how to revive it”

You said infinitely! I never used sustainability that way. Nuclear is not sustainable because there isn't enough uranium available to extract, certainly not in an environmentally friendly way, in order to meet an expanded demand for more than a few decades ▶ this video There is, however, more than enough minerals available to make machines that, once built, will continue to produce and store emission free power for their lifetimes. They are being increasingly made out of recyclable materials and there is other research into lowering their footprint further. In other words, actually sustainable - as in for thousands of years. Renewables aren't there yet, but they will be sooner if a fraction of the cost of new nuclear plants is diverted to the very promising R&D that already exists. Nuclear doesn't have nearly the same interest or rate of advancement into mitigating the serious environmental problems associated with producing and disposing of fuel, something your sources don't consider at all. You write like you've just discovered the life cycle 'true cost' of renewables while holding the unrevealed wisdom that nuclear isn't that dangerous. These things are obvious to anyone who follows this, people who would never make the mistake of calling nuclear sustainable. And I used to be a proponent of nuclear until around 6 months ago when I learned that there aren't enough resources available, and that nuclear won't be able to ramp up in time to lower the atmospheric carbon level increas

CitesView on HN
@Sporktacular2022 · in “Who killed nuclear energy and how to revive it”

link Or Sabine Hossenfelder's explanation ▶ this video Current reactors use U235 which is less than 1% of all Uranium on the planet. Don't know about reactors that use other uranium isotopes, but if after 70 years they are still at the design stage, it kind of makes my point. It's just too late to turn that around. The article just overlooks this fundamental problem.

CitesView on HN
@olejorgenb2022 · in “More invested in nuclear fusion in last 12 months than past decade”

She address fast-breeders and thorium in the same video: ▶ this video (concluding that they are too complex and expensive)

CitesView on HN
@spawarotti2022 · in “More invested in nuclear fusion in last 12 months than past decade”

How long will the fuel last? Sabine Hossenfelder references studies in which we have enough Uranium for 50 years max. 6:08 here: ▶ this video

CitesView on HN
@k__2022 · in “Why is the nuclear power industry stagnant?”

I was curious about new types of nuclear reactors. But, it turns out they still can't deliver what nuclear proponents claim. Sabine Hossenfelder explains it very well: ▶ this video

RecommendsView on HN
Hydrogen Will Not Save Us. Here's Why.20:02

Hydrogen Will Not Save Us. Here's Why.

Sabine Hossenfelder
2.4M views • 3 years ago
Why renewables can’t save the planet | Michael Shellenberger | TEDxDanubia17:33

Why renewables can’t save the planet | Michael Shellenberger | TEDxDanubia

TEDx Talks
5.7M views • 7 years ago
The Economics of Nuclear Energy16:11

The Economics of Nuclear Energy

Real Engineering
2M views • 6 years ago
Something's Rotten with French Nuclear1:11:06

Something's Rotten with French Nuclear

Decouple Media
12K views • 4 years ago
How close is nuclear fusion power?12:50

How close is nuclear fusion power?

Sabine Hossenfelder
764K views • 5 years ago
Why I changed my mind about nuclear power | Michael Shellenberger | TEDxBerlin20:29

Why I changed my mind about nuclear power | Michael Shellenberger | TEDxBerlin

TEDx Talks
2.3M views • 8 years ago
The Big Lie About Nuclear Waste13:04

The Big Lie About Nuclear Waste

Cleo Abram
4.8M views • 3 years ago
Is Nuclear Waste Really Waste?40:40

Is Nuclear Waste Really Waste?

Google TechTalks
75K views • 15 years ago
Innovating to zero! | Bill Gates29:33

Innovating to zero! | Bill Gates

TED
4.7M views • 16 years ago
Thorium: An energy solution - THORIUM REMIX 20111:59:59

Thorium: An energy solution - THORIUM REMIX 2011

gordonmcdowell
804K views • 15 years ago
Former fusion scientist on why we won't have fusion power by 204015:42

Former fusion scientist on why we won't have fusion power by 2040

Improbable Matter
2M views • 5 years ago
Economics of Nuclear Reactor23:10

Economics of Nuclear Reactor

Illinois EnergyProf
921K views • 7 years ago
The Liquid Fluoride Thorium Reactor:  What Fusion Wanted To Be55:17

The Liquid Fluoride Thorium Reactor: What Fusion Wanted To Be

Google TechTalks
390K views • 17 years ago
Dispelling the Myths of Nuclear Energy (Live Lecture)35:50

Dispelling the Myths of Nuclear Energy (Live Lecture)

Illinois EnergyProf
342K views • 5 years ago
The Thorium Molten-Salt Reactor: Why Didn't This Happen (and why is now the right time?)36:02

The Thorium Molten-Salt Reactor: Why Didn't This Happen (and why is now the right time?)

Google TechTalks
663K views • 14 years ago
Q&A - Helion Energy, NIF, Space and more3:19:02

Q&A - Helion Energy, NIF, Space and more

Improbable Matter
151K views • 3 years ago
Modular Micro-Reactors – The Future of Nuclear Energy?20:38

Modular Micro-Reactors – The Future of Nuclear Energy?

Illinois EnergyProf
169K views • 6 years ago
Energy From Thorium: A Nuclear Waste Burning Liquid Salt Thorium Reactor1:22:09

Energy From Thorium: A Nuclear Waste Burning Liquid Salt Thorium Reactor

Google TechTalks
164K views • 17 years ago
The Great Stranding: How Inaccurate Mainstream LCOE Estimates are Creating a Trillion-Dollar Bubble18:58

The Great Stranding: How Inaccurate Mainstream LCOE Estimates are Creating a Trillion-Dollar Bubble

RethinkX
38K views • 5 years ago
We Solved Nuclear Waste Decades Ago18:14

We Solved Nuclear Waste Decades Ago

Kyle Hill
4.5M views • 4 years ago